Culture and Decision Making

One of the most common errors that business leaders make is to take North American sound bites into a different culture. While some the dynamics of corporate culture are universal, many times it is not.

An example is that of the popular western approach to self-directed management. In the U.S. the culture is generally individualistic, resistant to restraints and the desire for everyone to feel like they are their own bosses, even if their job is at the bottom of the company hierarchy.

In many countries of Asia, Eastern Europe and much of Western Europe, hierarchical management drives the corporation. “Self” is not only discouraged, it is condemned.

A U.S. corporate coach outlined the differences between a coaching culture (inefficient and ineffective, in his estimation versus non-coaching culture (which he deemed superior).


In a non-coaching culture:

* Leaders tell others what to do and how to do it.

* Companies establish rules, structures and procedures to maintain control.

* Managers delegate responsibility with specific instructions and expectations.

* Bosses make decisions to be carried out by employees.

* Supervisors are judged by how much they know.

* Employees are expected to perform their work without question or feedback.

In a coaching culture:

* Leaders create visions, engage in dialogue and empower people to think critically, take risks and come up with their own solutions.

* Companies establish rules, structures and procedures through collaboration to enhance productivity.

* Managers allow freedom and creativity in carrying out assignments, with workers accountable for results, not the way they achieve those results.

* Bosses and workers make decisions together to attain goals in both the short term and the long term.

* Supervisors are judged by how effective their teams are.

* Employees are valued and encouraged to participate in the process, strategize and find solutions.

So which is better? One can make an argument for both sides, but that’s not the point. The issue is that corporation’s work differently based on their cultural rules. If a business does tries to impose their standard of operation on others they will fail every time. Learning culture means understanding how their systems work and make it better within their social work environment. Not to make them like us.